剧照
剧情介绍
本剧叙述在野党影子内阁成员Jim Hacker在帮助本党大选获胜之后得到行政事务部（DAA）部长的职务，从此开始面对以部秘书Sir Humphrey Appleby为首的公务员体系，而他的公派私人秘书、同属公务员的Bernard则夹在了当中。在Hacker所代表的政客以及Appleby所代表的公务员之间因施政而发生的种种冲突之中，两人的关系不停地发生变化，既有互相捂盖子，也有互相揭老底。与此同时，英国政治体制（包括政党体制和公务员体制）中的种种不为外人所知弊端和黑幕也展现在观众眼前。当然所有这些都是通过大量喜剧情节和台词展开。在本系列后半部分的《Yes Prime Minister》中，Hacker通过党内角力当上了首相，而Appleby也已先他一步当上了首相秘书，两人的故事移到唐宁街10号继续展开。道格拉吸血鬼第五节007之最高机密英语遇见你之后第二季枪神再起百夫长智利说不尉迟恭来自光芒的光战斗民族养成记嘿玛嘿玛钱2019美国甜心（2001）风之王小和尚大当家乘上独角兽地狱来的芳邻非主角的女友妙婿向钱冲两个心脏我的砍价女王王牌逗王牌街头女哨兵检察方的罪人（国语版）六尸案鬼网吧酷爱电影的庞波小姐魔鬼情人2002李响进城亲爱的小孩恋の墓我是女人怒吼吧！黄河少狼第四季忍者神龟1990男人花兼职罗曼史唐砖(下)灵域双生我太受欢迎了该怎么办少年魔法师第二季回火2
长篇影评
1 ) 看到好笑的就写下来
Three articles of Civil Service: it takes longer to do things quickly; it is more expensive to do them cheaply; it is more democratic to do them in secret
Civil servants are grown like oak trees, not mustard and cress.
A: tell him the unions won't wear it.
B: but they like it!
A: that's beside the point.
A: well, if I might suggest...that we be realistic about this.
B: by realistic, you mean drop the whole scheme?
A: oh, dear me, no! but perhaps, a pause to re-group, allow us to reassess the situation and discuss alternative strategies? a space of time for mature reflection and deliberation?
B: ...yes you mean drop the whole scheme.
A: you are not saying that government the Britain is important?
B: no! it is very important! it's just that I haven't met anyone who's doing it!
A: in the past all local government reforms rebound on us. whenever anybody finds a way of saving money or cutting staff in local government, you find it works for Whitehall just as well!
B: yes, but local government is extravagant, overstaffed, incompetent, whereas we...Σ( ° △ °|||)︴
A：╮(￣▽￣")╭
A: if he does need something to keep him busy, you know what to do? get him to look into civil defense.
B: Civil defense? you mean fallout shelters?o(*≧▽≦)ツ
A: yes, government long ago decided that civil defense was not a serious issue.
B: oh, merely a desperate one!o(*≧▽≦)ツ
A: and it is best left to those whose incompetence can be relied upon.
B: local authorities!o(*≧▽≦)ツ
A: people of local government are either self-centered busy bodies on an ego trip and the other half do it for what they can get out of it.
B: perhaps they ought to be in the House of Commons.
A: where did you get the idea for this dangerous nonsense?!!!
B: from someone...in the department.
A: minister! I have warned you before about the danger of speaking to people in the department! I implore you to stay out of the minefield of local government. it is a political graveyard.
C: excuse me, sir Humphrey, but you cannot have a graveyard in a minefield, because all the corpses would....powwwwww!
A: if local authorities don't send us statistics that we asked for, then the government figures will be a nonsense.
B: why?
A: they'll be incomplete!
B: but government figures are a nonsense anyway.
C: I think A wants to ensure they are complete nonsense.
If the minister is restless, he can feed the ducks in St Jame's Park!
Obviously I'm not a trained lawyer or I wouldn't have been in charge of the Legal Unit!!
Minister: Non-event?
Humphrey: Oh, a brilliant triumph for you of course, minister.
Minister: hmmm.
Humphrey: which is why it's a futile non-event for the press.
A: it's perfectly all right, as long as nobody knows.
B: shouldn't we tell minister?
A: certainly not!
B: but if everybody knows!
A: everybody else. we do not let a minister know what everybody else knows.
A: I can't believe it! are you saying that winning at corruption is government policy?
B: no, no! minister! It could never be government policy! that is unthinkable! ......only government practice...╮(￣▽￣")╭
A: Everything wrong is not having an integrated policy.
B: But we did have a policy before.
A: Did we?
B: Yes, it was our policy not to have a policy.
The ship of state is the only ship that leaks from the top!
2 ) BBC's take on Yes, Minister
Three series were made between 1980 and 1984, before Jim Hacker achieved real power in Yes Prime Minister.
<图片2>
The series follows Right Honorable James Hacker MP, Minister for Administrative Affairs, and his attempts to make officialdom and administration make sense. He does this whilst pushing his own self-serving agenda, and keeping his head above any nasty political waters. Throughout his career, he's up against Whitehall’s Sir Humphrey Appleby, unflappable symbol of a machine that has no gears, only brakes.
Jim's policies, whether cutting costs or trying to streamline red tape, are sabotaged by Appleby's Machiavellian skills, often accompanied by brain-wrenching sentences designed to confuse Hacker - and often succeeding. Absolutely snobbish and elitist, yet blind to anything that does not serve the Whitehall way, Sir Humphrey is the avatar of the British State.
<图片3>
Hacker's politics appear to be completely pragmatic and blown by the winds of chance, and are never dogmatic enough to be clearly labelled Labour or Conservative. By removing the trappings of a particular 'party' and allowing both sides to appear at their worst - venal and inconstant Hacker forever opposing the pompous and manipulative Appleby - Yes, Minister maintained a timeless quality that means it has endured beyond the Thatcherite politics it satirised.
Issues were raised that are still timely now - identity papers and computer databases of the population, university funding, arms sales, oil politics being just a few.
<图片4>
Motifs of the series included the wonderful music of Ronnie Hazelhurst playing against Gerald Scarfe's hilarious caricatures of the three leads; Hacker's use of catastrophically mixed metaphors, his Private Secretary Bernard's fondness for awful puns and maddening pedantry, and Sir Humphrey's laconic wit, almost shocking contempt for anyone who isn't a senior Civil Servant, and his catchphrase, usually after totally defeating Hacker, of muttering 'Yes Minster' to close the show.
<图片5>
Whilst the iconic figure of Sir Humphrey, as portrayed by Nigel Hawthorne, is the series' enduring legacy, the true star of the show is Hacker, as played by Paul Eddington. Though most of the verbal quips are Humphrey's, the comedy is Hacker's, mainly because Paul Eddington was probably the best comedy actor of his generation and his timing is miraculous.
Always buffeted by fate, wanting to do good but too scared of losing votes and status to do anything, Hacker is the symbol of all of us, wanting to be better, and not quite making it.
A true original, Yes Minister remains one of the most influential sitcoms of its time, as witness its huge success, many awards (including BAFTAs for the show and for Hawthorne).
<图片6>
Famously accurate in the spirit of the relationship between civil servant and politician, it was Mrs Thatcher's favourite show... make of that whatever you want. Yes Minister was proof that comedy could take on serious subjects and make real points with them.
搬运自BBC-Comedy Yes, Minister
3 ) 《是 大臣》第三季观后感
很难想象英国人20世纪80年代的剧集即使放到今天也不过时，在看完剧后，你会发现各国的政治体制虽然有所不同，但官僚机构的行事作风却大同小异。
第一集主题是男女平权，我觉得结尾莎拉的话值得回味，她的对话表明女性要的不是男性施舍的平等，她们希望得到的是一个平等竞争和证明自己能力的机会。然而这一点却不能被哈克汉弗莱等人理解，最终导致了她的出走。
第二第三集略过不谈。
第四集是我感慨较深的一集，哈克在危机时刻毫不犹豫地想要出卖忠心耿耿的伯纳，说明哈克本质上也是一个自私自利的人。此外，哈克的临场应变能力也确实让人刮目相看，为其日后成为首相埋好伏笔。
第五、六、七、八集略过。
虽然汉弗莱是道德真空，但他的部分观点不无道理，如公务员的政治中立、政府的首要职责在于维护社会稳定等。
4 ) 走管理路线怎么可以少了经典素材积累
1. The three articles of civil service faith: it takes longer to do things quickly; it's more expensive to do them cheaply; it's more democratic to do them in secret.
2. 阿拉伯之旅答记者问也是模板，以守为攻不然都快被pua到忘了minister这个位置也不是随便什么阿猫阿狗能爬上来的
Do come in.
Sit down, Jenny.
I may call you Jenny, may I not?
- If you like.
- Now, what seems to be the trouble? Two things.Both of them rather worrying to the public.The first is a story that was in the French press.It's about corruption in BES
- getting the Kumrani contract.
- Complete nonsense!
- They quoted reports of payments to officials.Really, this is absolutely typical.A British company slogs its guts out to win orders, create jobs! What does it get from the media? A smear campaign! - If they won by bribery
- There was no bribery.I had a full inquiry.
- All these payments have been identified.
- What as?
- Commission fees, administrative overheads.
- Operative costs, managerial surcharges.Expenses, miscellaneous outgoings.We have looked into every brown envelope every every account book and everything is completely in order.
- I see.
- May I say one thing? Allegations of this nature are symptomatic of a very sick society for which the media shares the blame!
- The media?
- Why are you putting thousands of jobs at risk? I'll call on the Press Council to censure the press for its lack of professionalism in running this story.The Council and the House of Commons must be concerned about the standards which have applied in this disgraceful matter.Pressure will be brought to bear to make sure that this gutter press reporting is not repeated.I see.Ahem.Well, there is this other question.It's about the rosewater jar apparently presented to you in Kumran.
- Yes?
- I saw it in your flat, actually.
- Yes, we're keeping it there, temporarily.
- Temporarily?
- Yes, it's very valuable.
- Mrs Hacker said it was an imitation.Burglars, girl, burglars! And you've gossip! That's until we can get rid of it.
- Get rid of it?
- I'll present it to our local museum this weekend.I can't hold onto it, you know.It's government property.Now what was your question? No er that's all right, actually.Um I No, no, no, that's fine.
- Nothing more?
- No, no, that's all.Well, good of you to drop in.
- Thank you, Minister.
- Goodbye, Jenny.
5 ) 为什么我们需要Jim Hacker
万万没想到，data structure考试前两天，急需复习的时候，居然在拖延时被这部最近治愈我的喜剧打了鸡血。
三季下来，每一集都是精确讽刺，讨论到的问题也是非常超前。每个事件开头minister都会发表一场politicians惯常的假大空发言，怀着一些天真和正义感想要做出一些改变，最后被sir humphrey描绘出的政府真相和可能损伤个人利益的状况劝退，成为一个不上不下，毫无实际作为的政治家。一直到最后一集，成为首相也是机缘巧合，暗地合作达成，一番激昂的演讲不过是为选举推波助澜，用激起爱国主义的空泛词句堆砌而成。
但我还是莫名其妙被感动到了！！不是内容本身，而是看到了他作为一个人的优势，觉得我们都那么不同，但会找到适合自己的位置的！minister平时看起来只会萌混过关，在演讲时严肃的样子却熠熠生辉。这样带动感染人群的能力，就是他拥有而其他人，比如比他聪明无数倍的humphrey所没有的。我们都应该多多发掘自己的优势与长处，发展它们，要相信这些东西总会有用武之地的。
看到最后一集突然明白，为什么人类社会需要Jim Hacker这样的人。我们都看得到眼前现实的黑暗，但我们需要偶尔有机会抬头看看美好的东西，我们需要高尚的概念来支撑我们努力活下去，哪怕我们都看得到它的虚伪，它还是必不可少的。我想到前两天听podcast推荐了安迪威尔的新书拯救计划，其中一位点评说为什么他喜欢安迪威尔，就是因为他的故事在可读性之外，总是包含了一种坚强的，乐观的精神，他传递出了一种人类社会的“光明与黑暗”的，也许有些cheesy的“正确”价值观，让点评者觉得看到了对未来的希望，因为起码这样的分辨力和道德感还存在于人类心中。同样，Yes Minister如果没有这最后一集，我只会觉得这是一部故事非常有趣的，辛辣的讽刺剧。因为有了这一集，我才明白democracy与文学与音乐与电影一样，它存在的意义就是造梦。Jim Hacker的价值就在于他的天真，像Annie所说的，他和Sir Humphrey和其他的civil servants不同点就在于，他心中还一直保有一些道德判断，还不是vacuum，还相信改变，还时不时会做梦。人类社会需要做梦，需要这样的乐观精神才能延续。
最近很多情绪的来源，就是发现自己常常在幻想和现实之间摇摆不定。一方面理性在告诉自己，要明白自己的平凡，要去爱具体的人，要感恩生活中小小的事情，不要好高骛远觉得自己above周围人。另一方面我的心又总像火山般的躁动，像平原上的刘晓样，像悲剧的包法利夫人，像千千万万的理想主义者，觉得很多东西我就是无法妥协，无法接受做一个只在乎眼前平凡生活的普通人。我觉得我deserve better，belong somewhere better，觉得我只要踮踮脚尖就可以够到更光明的未来，有更多可能性和开放的人生。看我这一集我想，没什么好纠结的，因为人生就是这样的摇摆不定。大多数时候像Jim一样，我们选择认命，接受现实，在道貌巍然之下悄悄地拥抱自己自私的人性的一面。但总有时刻我们会开始做梦，会情绪高涨，会自己感动自己，会被自己的大口号打鸡血。这两种状态对生活都是必须的，平凡的日子就脚踏实地的努力，只是永远不要放弃做梦的那个自己，搞不好哪天就像Jim走狗屎运，坐到了（理论上）能改变世界的位置呢？
6 ) 吉姆哈克的双面人生
由于“糟糕”的补片顺序，全系列看的最后一集是第三季第六集。
不知道是最后一集的缘故还是因为这集本身剧情偏伤感：哈克在成为10号的前夕，为正义挺身而出，和汉弗莱争论武器出口的问题。即使是在哈克与汉皮的许多争吵中，这也算是颇为激烈的一次。当哈克怒斥汉弗莱”道德真空“时，这次争执就显得尤其不同了。这不是关于官僚机构或是竞选拉票之类的老话题，在哈克的角度上来看，这事关许许多多无辜的生命，关乎一切被摆在政治的桌面上的美丽口号，即使是从最朴素的角度上来看，哈克仍认为他所服务的政府没有理由不和他一样关切此事。当然，除非英格兰已尽如汉弗莱爵士一般，道德真空。
这是真正承前启后的一集，哈克完成了成为10号前的最后一步，除了他已具备的”灵活“和”善于纳谏“，不列颠的组织部秘书很快教会了哈克最后一课——道德真空。如果说从前的哈克的双面人生指的是向民众许下的空头支票和向官僚体系的靠近的矛盾的话，那从此之后哈克将认为二者是一致的，无非是前者在结果上欺骗，后者在过程上欺骗。
与全系列喜悦的基调不同，这集多少有些沉重。观众已经习惯了在剧中正义得不到伸张，但哈克满怀希望却被现实击垮的样子如同告诉观众，在现实中也需要习惯正义得不到伸张。
哈克睡倒在沙发上，手里抓着酒瓶，口中大声喊叫着“whisky priest”，浓浓醉意容不得他去回忆从报社到唐宁街的一切，从旁观者到当局者，从谎言到背叛。妻子在一旁看着醉酒的丈夫温柔地说出那句"Yes, minister"，哈克意识到她是唯一自始自终仍相信着自己的人：相信吉姆哈克没有双面人生，吉姆哈克如一地服务着他的理想与认知，吉姆哈克是个善良且诚实的人。
在遇见这剧之前我从来不知道世界上居然拍这种题材能有这么个拍法的(以前更加孤陋寡闻嗯），人物塑造各种对话单独挑哪里出来都是一等一的赞，萌爆了的剧（等等
笑死了笑死了，必须起身鼓掌送给这群老头，真是太有趣了，好高端漂亮的英文词汇句子啊。恭喜haker成为了10号!!!!!!9.8分!!!果然是神剧
這一季的服裝很不錯。Humpy往事被揭露簡直太經典，Bernard充分發掘了自己的潛力，Hacker的學習成果得到了導師的肯定XD
1.女性主义；2. 精简冗余公务员、民防工程与“领导先躲”&媒体“自由” 3. 打压高效地方政府&掩盖历史失责档案 4. 公务员蹭出国&外贸行贿订单&公务员家属受贿；5. 陆运空运铁路-公共交通；6.军火与恐怖分子&道德真空；7.花大部分老百姓的税补贴少数精英趣味（歌剧院音乐厅美术馆等）还是大部分老百姓的平民娱乐
三星半。特别篇的条目找不到了及写在这儿吧~ jim还是成功上位了啊！！ 经过了这么多事儿你说jim真什么都不知道吗？真傻吗？切~凭我的智商反正是做不到他这个程度~最后游说竞选人的部分赶脚jim超有范儿啊~干脆利落！等着你呦PM~
这剧本，这表演，这从句套从句套从句套从句的表达。。。= = 三位主演两位已逝，只有Bernard一人看新版YM是如何糟蹋经典的。
第一集的女权问题放到三十年后的今天也是最常被谈论的话题，而在1900的精讲里，弹幕里男人的反驳和跳脚和坐在会议室里的英国老白男如出一辙，感觉什么都没有变，什么都没有解决，哪有什么矫枉过正，争取权利就是进十退九。
期待唐宁街10号再见~以后碰到说话绕弯的人就这么问"You're not related to Sir Humphrey Appleby by any chance?" 另外，Bernard越来越可爱了~
打岔的艺术、下套的艺术、扯皮的艺术、装傻的艺术、捅娄子的艺术、补锅的艺术……
圣诞特别篇真是首尾呼应的典范，既呼应了本集开头给Bernard的surprise，也呼应了本剧第一季第一集的phone jitters. 只是首相突然提早离职的安排也太奇怪了。
都是些道德中空的人，不过因为自己的良心而否定他人的道德未免太过了，所以我们要做的事是什么也不理，做自己职责内的事罢了PS难得有三人“合作”简直不是棒字了得，开始喜欢狡诈却明智的Humphey了，大臣真的很萌
这后面几集伯纳德戏份越来越多，也越来越智慧了，不过伯纳德衰老得好快！汉弗莱确实魅力四射虽说并不是啥善人。最后哈克给伯纳德升官，汉弗莱不高兴，估计是觉得他俩关系太近了吧。
除了关于性别问题的那集笑不出来外 其他还是好好笑啊:D
可能是这辈子看到的最好的剧了吧
完美的“大臣奋斗三部曲”，从第一季刚进内阁不了解情况、被秘书玩弄于股掌之间，到第二季熟悉规则、有时还利用秘书反击一下，这第三季算是修得圆满、与秘书配合默契并同化了，互相掩护、打官腔也熟练不少、对官僚运作机制了解颇深。而私人秘书伯纳虽然也适应了两面派生活，但经常抛书袋，没多少长进。
太机智了！连Bernard半真半假的回答都闪耀着智慧的光芒！嘤~
一集一集看下来真的是非常过瘾，而且越陷越深...所谓神剧和经典的确有它的魔力，如今很火的《House of cards》一集就看不下去了，感谢这部剧，让我一个政治盲得到了启蒙。无可救药的爱上这部剧了，不因为它到底有多搞笑，而是看着它就给人很惬意温馨的感觉。三个人都好可爱，特别是Bernard好萌！！！2021.9二刷，大概从第三集开始非常赞了！
minister想把Bernard当弃子给扔掉的时候我可伤心了！！！(╬￣皿￣)凸虽然Bernard总是墙头草两边倒，可是人家总是尽力帮助minister你呢！！怎么还不如humpy对Bernard 呢！(╬￣皿￣)凸还好最好Bernard的事情被压下来了！
第七集绝了，民膏民脂供有权有势的人享乐
《THE WHISKY PRIEST》这一集系列最佳，以前看的话我应会流泪。